This Avalon Home Was Rumored to be a Speakeasy
Built more than a century ago, the charming blue home on Sedalia Avenue still has an original red window that signaled when the bar was open for business.
When Chad Helbling and his family were looking for a home in 2018, they knew they wanted to stay in the boroughs north of the city that they already knew and loved — just with a little more privacy and some room to sprawl out.
They found exactly what they were looking for at 2 Sedalia Ave. in Avalon. Over the next eight years, thoughtful updates to the decor and mechanics of the charming blue home, which was built in 1893, made the perfect buy even better.
Perched above Avalon Park, which contains a pool, a new playground, basketball courts, a creek for wading and pavilions, Helbling says the property’s location is truly the best of both worlds when it comes to accessibility and personal space.
“We love the walkability, but also the privacy,” he says. “We loved being able to walk to the park, baseball fields and restaurants.”
Before buying the home, Helbling says his family adored its wraparound front porch and detailed woodwork in the front foyer. It was easy for them to see how they could add their own touches to enhance the already baked-in charm.
“The house has so much original character, like the tin ceilings, that we fell in love,” says Helbling.
The home’s age and history, which came with a touch of scandal, also intrigued them. Amidst timely updates, Helbling says they kept a few fun authentic details intact.
“The red window above the front door is the original glass panel,” he says. “Apparently, they would put a candle next to it back during Prohibition and had a mini speakeasy in the basement.”
Helbling’s experience as a local contractor contributed to the home’s wow factor, says Realtor Nancy Snider of Coldwell Banker, who has listed the 1,700-square-foot home for $335,000.
“The updates are thoughtful, especially in the kitchen and powder room area,” says Snider.
The kitchen, which has white cabinets and a mix of marble-look and butcher block countertops, is spacious enough to cook for a family or host company. A mix of cabinetry and open shelving for display creates a homey feel.
The adjacent dining room is also nicely sized and lined with floor-to-ceiling bookshelves along one wall. Outside is an incredible oasis, which includes a covered patio, mature trees and a privacy fence
“I love the creative use of the outdoor space,” says Snider. “The seller was able to create wonderful entertaining spaces and a lovely covered deck.”
The easy flow between the rooms on the first floor makes entertaining easy and inviting. The tin ceilings, original millwork and three decorative fireplaces all add to the home’s cozy vibe.
Upstairs, the top two floors share one full bathroom; three bedrooms are on the second floor, while the third floor contains the fourth bedroom, which also could be used as a flex space. The basement is partially finished and suitable for a workshop, lounge or storage. The attached two-car garage has a flat roof that was recently recoated as well.
Helbling adds that a sense of community among neighbors is another highlight of living on Sedalia Avenue. “The neighborhood is full of young families as well as retirees that have been there most of their lives,” he says.
It’s fun around the holidays, too, with no shortage of impromptu block parties.
“It is a great trick-or-treating neighborhood, and Santa still comes by every Christmas Eve on a firetruck,” Helbling says.








