Steelers’ ‘Fiasco in Cincinnati’ Disappointing, Not Definitive

The team will reveal who they are in their next game, much more than they did in their recent loss to the Bengals.

PITTSBURGH STEELERS QUARTERBACK AARON RODGERS DURING A REGULAR SEASON GAME BETWEEN THE PITTSBURGH STEELERS AND THE CINCINNATI BENGALS, THURSDAY, OCT. 16, 2025 IN CINCINNATI, OH. | PHOTO BY KARL ROSER/PITTSBURGH STEELERS

The Steelers may have been undressed by the Bengals, but they were not exposed.

Contrary to the growing media narrative, locally and nationally — and the increasing number of fans who are in danger of pulling hamstrings jumping off the bandwagon — Bengals 38, Steelers 18 was one game.

Granted, it was an ugly a game, as ugly a game as the Steelers have played in recent memory.

The final score doesn’t begin to accurately reflect the profoundly one-sided nature of the “Collapse in Cincinnati,” or the “Ambush in Cincinnati,” or the “Disaster in Cincinnati.” (Take your pick.)

“I have never seen the Pittsburgh Steelers embarrassed in a half of football like that,” NBC’s Cris Collinsworth assessed after the opening 30 minutes of the game.

The second half wasn’t any better. But to maintain that such a performance betrayed the Steelers as frauds is a stretch.

The teams beat those very same Bengals back in September.

That one counts, too. So do the other five victories the Steelers achieved on the way to compiling the 6-2 record they took with them to Cincinnati.
Revelations of a definitive nature are hard to come by during a 17-game season. If you’re determined to find one anyway, look no further than this coming Sunday in Philadelphia.

That’s when we’ll really find out who these Steelers are.

The “Cincinnati Debacle” was costly because it gave the Bengals a leg up in the race for the AFC North Division championship, and because it pushed the Steelers further away from contention for a first or second seed in the AFC playoffs and closer to the conversation about a Wild Card invitation to the postseason.

So be it.

There are still two months of regular-season games to be played.

Respond as necessary and the “Catastrophe in Cincinnati” can be worked around if not forgotten.

Still, if the Steelers don’t respond immediately against the Eagles, then the fraud accusations will gain credence, and the fans may be justified in jumping off the bandwagon and searching next for the nearest bridge.

The loss of guard Mason McCormick is significant collateral damage, emotionally and intangibly, as well as along an offensive line the Steelers are still counting upon to forge their offensive identity. If McCormick proves to be the Jenga piece, then the Steelers weren’t the team they thought they could be all along.
Overcoming the Eagles minus McCormick certainly ought not to be a Walt Whitman Bridge too far.

That’s Joe Milton III they’ll be playing against this Sunday, not Joe Burrow. If Milton starts as anticipated, he’ll do so in an NFL game for the second time in his three-year career.

Philadelphia’s alternative at QB is Tanner McKee, who, likewise, never has and never will be confused with Burrow, the presumptive NFL MVP.

The Eagles’ current losing streak has reached an NFL-worst seven consecutive games. They’ve dealt with and are still trying to work around multiple injuries, their All-World right offensive tackle Lane Johnson retired in-season, they were selling off pieces in advance of the NFL trade deadline, and the stars they haven’t traded are in many cases unrecognizable. For example, running back Saquon Barkley had 22 rushing yards on 13 attempts on Nov. 8 against the New York Football Giants.

Head coach Nick Sirianni is considered to be a dead man walking in Philly, where the torches and pitchforks may well be visible should the Steelers manage to grab a 3-0 lead.

The NFL offers no guarantees, but this is nonetheless the get-right game the Steelers need about now.

Take care of business in preparation, win it convincingly and then look ahead to Denver. That’s the response the “Calamity in Cincinnati” demands.

That, and to push back the urge to panic, at least until after Thanksgiving.

Categories: Mike Prisuta’s Sports Section, The 412