Review: Meat & Potatoes

Visit this modern-day Pittsburgh speakeasy for decadent comfort food and top-notch mixed drinks.




Photos by Laura Petrilla
 

 

What is a gastropub? According to chef Richard DeShantz, owner of the new Cultural District restaurant Meat & Potatoes, it’s a pub that serves high-end or craft food and libations. Meat & Potatoes is a modern-day Pittsburgh speakeasy, with a Paris-meets-Brooklyn interior, a wealth of interesting mixed drinks—including those honoring both Prohibition and “the Repeal”—and decadent food that will excite your taste buds, warm your belly and (depending on what you order) prompt visits to your cardiologist.

Owners Tolga Sedvik and DeShantz are also the forces behind Nine on Nine, a nearby fine-dining spot. DeShantz opened Meat & Potatoes to offer something different from his other venture: “food that a chef would eat after a busy day at work, food you grew up with, comfort food and street food.”

The central focal point of the stylized restaurant is, no doubt, the large wood, granite-topped bar that seats 30. The drink menu offers intriguing mixed drinks with names like the Aviation and the Dark & Smokey. Try one of the Barrel-Aged drinks, cocktails mixed and then aged in an oak barrel for two months, giving the components time to integrate, while the wood imparts vanilla, caramel, or spicy notes. I had a barrel-aged Manhattan ($11), and it was magnificent. The restaurant also offers absinthe drinks (Grand Absente $14 and Vieux Carre $12), an extensive selection of reasonably priced bottled and draught beers ($3-$7), and about a dozen each of red and white wines by the glass ($8-$19) or bottle ($32-$76).

Meat & Potatoes' interior is evocative of an era gone by, incorporating bare Edison light bulbs with glowing orange filaments, brown velveteen chairs and booths, tall mirrors, 1920s-style sconces, and a concrete floor. My compliments to DeShantz and his brother, who designed and built this hipster-meets-chophouse interior. The space, the menu (a single sheet of brown parchment with “old thyme” styling), the mounted cow head on the wall, a chalkboard illustration of beef cuts and the fun serveware (drinks in juice glasses, dish towels for napkins, cast-iron pots and desserts in jelly jars) work together to make a coherent experience not common enough in local restaurants.

The ceiling is high, and the tabletops are granite—so it’s a noisy place. But the noise is from conversation and laughter (and, thankfully, not TVs) and is part of the experience: This is the kind of place where you sit at the bar, order a whiskey and Devils on Horseback (a $6 retro, stuffed date appetizer) and talk about politics.

My favorite appetizer is the Moules ($14), which changes daily. An abundance of steamed mussels are served in a black pot with a lid; when the lid is opened, the mussels release their fragrant steam. The ones I ate were steamed in a spicy and satisfying curry, lime and chili-pepper broth, which was so good that I requested a spoon to make sure I didn’t miss a drop.

I enjoyed the mac-n-cheese ($12), featuring bits of pork-belly pastrami and peas, and the very good lobster risotto ($14): thankfully not overcooked or clumpy and abundant with lobster chunks. A traditional salad that fits right in is the wedge ($7), featuring baby iceberg, bacon, roasted tomatoes, croutons and pickled onions, with a creamy and (not too blue) blue-cheese dressing.

The appetizer that has become the talk of the town is the bone marrow ($14): three roasted, halved bones about 8 inches long that, together, provide an outrageous amount (maybe a cup) of marrow, served with little ramekins of capers, onion relish, sea salt and gremalota to help cut the richness. The San Marzano flatbread ($10), however, is not remarkable, featuring homemade dough, tomato, Mozzarella cheese, prosciutto, artichoke and olives.

I was miffed when I learned that the housemade bread cost $3 for a few hearty slices. But when I tasted this bread, grilled and served with butter and homemade rhubarb compote, my feelings softened.

Among the main courses, my top picks were the “Mom” Meat Loaf ($16): a sweet, tomato-y loaf, served with perfect buttermilk mashed potatoes, spicy tomatoe [sic] jam and fried leeks; and the hamburger ($14, not always available): a special version topped with cheddar cheese and short ribs, served on a super fresh housemade bun. The fried taters are salty and delicious; be sure to ask for the truffle mayonnaise, which elevates the fries to a whole new level. Another excellent choice (and better for the heart) is the grilled bronzino fish ($22), served whole with roasted summer vegetables.

The chicken pot pie ($20) is beautifully served in an oval cast-iron pot, full of tender chicken, potatoes, peas and carrots; although it was soupy, the flavors were terrific. The hanger steak ($24) is a menu staple: chunky steak served with a little Southwestern flair, provided by chimichurri sauce, delicious grilled plantains and black-bean salsa.

For those with big appetite, there is a daily over-the-top selection, such as the ribeye ($42, which sold out when I was there), a 40-ounce prime rib or a 30-ounce porterhouse.

The desserts are served in jelly jars. I tried the rich, creamy chocolate pot de crème ($7), which had a rich dark-chocolate flavor. The key lime pie was also delicious, but I wasn’t jazzed about the presentation, excavating the crust from the bottom of a jelly jar.

My biggest gripe with Meat & Potatoes was the amount of time it took to receive my food, which appeared to be the fault of the kitchen staff, not the waitstaff. I’m going to chalk this up to the newness of the place and its overwhelming initial success, serving up to 350 customers per night during the first month of operation. And if you are rushing to see a show, be sure to tell your server after you're seated.

Although it's a drinking environment, the restaurant is kid-friendly, offering plain pasta with butter, hot dogs and hamburgers (all offerings aren't listed on the menu). And despite the name, the restaurant also offers several vegetarian dishes, including pasta, risotto, and flatbread, and keeps tempeh and seitan on hand for special requests. 
 

Info:
» 649 Penn Ave., Pittsburgh, PA (15222); 412/325-7007, meatandpotatoespgh.com
» Mon.-Thurs., 5-11 p.m.; Fri., 5 p.m.-12 a.m.; Sat. brunch 10 a.m.-2 p.m., dinner 5 p.m.-12 a.m.; Sun. brunch 10 a.m.-2 p.m., dinner 4-9 p.m.; contact restaurant to check on lunch
» Snacks, $3-$7; Appetizers & Salads, $7-$14; Main Courses, $16-$24; Desserts, $6
» Full bar, major credit cards accepted, reservations suggested, some vegetarian options, wheelchair-accessible, no smoking, $10 corkage fee, catering/banquet services, gluten-friendly options, downtown parking garages (with validation $4 at adjacent Theatre Square Garage at Penn Avenue & 7th Street).

 

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

Top 10 Things to Do in Pittsburgh in December

Top 10 Things to Do in Pittsburgh in December

This month's best bets in The 'Burgh.
50+ Things That Will Make You Enjoy Winter in Pittsburgh

50+ Things That Will Make You Enjoy Winter in Pittsburgh

Love it or hate it, winter is upon us. Because some of us may think there's a lot not to like, we bring you 50+ things to eat, drink and do –– and some helpful tips –– that'll keep the blues at bay.
Excellence in Nursing: Meet Our 2016 Honorees

Excellence in Nursing: Meet Our 2016 Honorees

Pittsburgh Magazine presents the honorees from its inaugural Excellence in Nursing awards. Meet our judges' choices and learn what makes them remarkable in their field.
Choreographed Style: Winter Fashion with The Pittsburgh Ballet

Choreographed Style: Winter Fashion with The Pittsburgh Ballet

A regal ruggedness characterizes the season's menswear looks.
Edit ModuleShow Tags

The 412

The Mosaic Stairway: You've Never Seen Steps Like These

The Mosaic Stairway: You've Never Seen Steps Like These

When viewed from the foot of the South Side Slopes of Pittsburgh, the stairs ascending Josephine Street form a massive image that consists of more than 7,500 individual mosaic tiles.
Joe Manganiello Plays the Good Guy for Children’s Hospital

Joe Manganiello Plays the Good Guy for Children’s Hospital

The actor, director and Mt. Lebanon native is joining the board of trustees of the Children’s Hospital of Pittsburgh Foundation.
Pittsburgh Man Sets World Record By Lifting 1 Million Pounds

Pittsburgh Man Sets World Record By Lifting 1 Million Pounds

Matt Scoletti accomplishes the feat in just under nine hours.
Why Thanksgiving Comes Every Day for 3 Pittsburgh-Area Men

Why Thanksgiving Comes Every Day for 3 Pittsburgh-Area Men

They owe their lives to one man who lives on in each of them.
Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

Top 10 Things to Do in Pittsburgh in December

Top 10 Things to Do in Pittsburgh in December

This month's best bets in The 'Burgh.
50+ Things That Will Make You Enjoy Winter in Pittsburgh

50+ Things That Will Make You Enjoy Winter in Pittsburgh

Love it or hate it, winter is upon us. Because some of us may think there's a lot not to like, we bring you 50+ things to eat, drink and do –– and some helpful tips –– that'll keep the blues at bay.
Excellence in Nursing: Meet Our 2016 Honorees

Excellence in Nursing: Meet Our 2016 Honorees

Pittsburgh Magazine presents the honorees from its inaugural Excellence in Nursing awards. Meet our judges' choices and learn what makes them remarkable in their field.
Choreographed Style: Winter Fashion with The Pittsburgh Ballet

Choreographed Style: Winter Fashion with The Pittsburgh Ballet

A regal ruggedness characterizes the season's menswear looks.
Restaurant Review: B52 in Lawrenceville is a Levantine Lifter

Restaurant Review: B52 in Lawrenceville is a Levantine Lifter

Omar Abuhejleh taps deep into his roots at his vegan cafe that's focused on Levantine cuisine.
Why You Can't Beat The Weather in Pittsburgh in The Winter

Why You Can't Beat The Weather in Pittsburgh in The Winter

I’ve traveled a lot of miles, and I still stare in bewilderment at people who tell me they’ve moved to a place because “You can’t beat the weather.”
Edit Module
Edit Module

Edit ModuleShow Tags

On the Blogs


The Mosaic Stairway: You've Never Seen Steps Like These

The Mosaic Stairway: You've Never Seen Steps Like These

When viewed from the foot of the South Side Slopes of Pittsburgh, the stairs ascending Josephine Street form a massive image that consists of more than 7,500 individual mosaic tiles.

Comments


All the foodie news that's fit to blog
The Café Carnegie Now Open in Oakland

The Café Carnegie Now Open in Oakland

Chefs Sonja Finn and Becca Hegarty helm the refurbished restaurant at the Carnegie Museums.

Comments


Not just good stuff. Great stuff.
Best of the Burgh: Pumpkin Patches in the Pittsburgh Area

Best of the Burgh: Pumpkin Patches in the Pittsburgh Area

We’ve compiled the best pumpkin patches for fall family fun.

Comments


Why Wait For Summer? Head to Kennywood's Holiday Lights

Why Wait For Summer? Head to Kennywood's Holiday Lights

The park's winter celebration is great for families and a fine choice for anyone who loves Christmas (and/or funnel cake).

Comments


Mike Prisuta's Sports Section

A weekly look at the games people are playing and the people who are playing them.
Big Ten-Champion Nittany Lions More Worthy Than Buckeyes

Big Ten-Champion Nittany Lions More Worthy Than Buckeyes

For some reason Ohio State is ranked No. 2 in the latest playoff rankings and Penn State is No. 7. That has to change if Penn State beats Wisconsin on Saturday night.

Comments


Style. Design. Goods. Hide your credit card.
Locket Full of Joy

Locket Full of Joy

The handcrafted piece opens to hidden treasures.

Comments


The movies that are playing in Pittsburgh –– and, more importantly, whether or not they're worth your time.
Ten Upcoming Flicks Every Oscar-Watcher Should See

Ten Upcoming Flicks Every Oscar-Watcher Should See

PM film critic Sean Collier picks ten forthcoming flicks likely to rake in nominations for the 89th Academy Awards.

Comments


Everything you need to know about getting married in Pittsburgh today.
Thinking Small: Pittsburgh Weddings That Are Intimate Affairs

Thinking Small: Pittsburgh Weddings That Are Intimate Affairs

Bigger isn’t always better, at least when it comes to these couples’ wedding ceremonies.

Comments


The latest tips and trends to refresh your home.
Seasonal Shopping: CMOA Store Holiday House, J.Crew Mercantile Opens Doors

Seasonal Shopping: CMOA Store Holiday House, J.Crew Mercantile Opens Doors

The Carnegie Museum of Art is full of Christmas cheer — and great deals. Plus, get the scoop on The Block Northway’s latest retail offering.

Comments


The hottest topics in higher education
Classic Christmas Tale Gets a Twist at Slippery Rock University

Classic Christmas Tale Gets a Twist at Slippery Rock University

An adapted version of “A Christmas Carol” will be presented during a seven-show run.

Comments