25 Superb Pittsburgh Pizzas

We scoured the metro area to find 25 of the best pies.



(page 1 of 4)


Photos by Heather Mull, Rob Larson, Laura Petrilla and Duane Rieder
 

 

Fact: Pittsburghers love pizza. And if you ask anyone to name their favorite local spot, you’re bound to get a passionate, lengthy response. So in order to choose 25 pizza spots worth mentioning, our restaurant critic, Valentina, traveled far and wide, eating innumerable piping-hot slices on-site. The findings? Categories like American, gourmet and authentic Italian no longer apply, since most places offer gourmet toppings, and authenticity is usually based on a specific time and region in Italy.

However, we discovered that there is a significant difference between pizzas cooked in regular and wood-fired ovens. (Some joints heat gas or electric ovens to 450-500 degrees and bake pies for up to 15 minutes, while others cook 'em for five minutes or less in 900-degree wood-fired ovens.) Our list includes a mix of tried-and-true fan favorites (such as Mineo’s, Aiello’s and Pasquarelli’s), and newcomers (like Spak Bros., Slice on Broadway and Cucina Bella), all worthy of recognition. Enjoy!
 



Slice on Broadway

Slice on Broadway's reputation brings people from all around. The shop’s slogan — “In perpetual pursuit of pizza perfection” — is backed by a commitment to making everything from scratch.  Select your own toppings or choose one of 15 specialty pizzas, such as the “Green Monster” with pesto, spinach, artichoke hearts, goat cheese and roasted red peppers.

Best-seller: Margherita

2128 Broadway Ave., Beechview
412/531-1068, sliceonbroadway.com


Napoli Pizzeria

Providing a traditional American-style pizza, Napoli goes light on the tomato sauce, and has a slightly salty cheese and dough.  This shop truly adds to the Murray Avenue pizza scene.
   
Best-seller: Pepperoni

2006 Murray Ave., Squirrel Hill
412/521-1744, napolipizzasqhill.com


Bado's Cucina

Using grandma’s crust recipe, chef Sam Badolato’s pizzas stay close to Italy with options ranging from the Bianco to the interesting mushroom truffle flatbread. Receiving many accolades for its wood-fired fare (including one of our 2011 Best Restaurants awards), Bado’s Cucina is a prime spot for pizza buffs to dine with their uninitiated comrades.

Best-seller: Margherita

3825 Washington Road, McMurray
724/942-3904, badoscucina.com


Cucina Bella

A relative newcomer, Cucina Bella is a pretty little place with a checkerboard floor and pizza at center stage (along with antipasto, salads, paninis and calzones). The pizza crust is crisp at the edges, and the toppings are classics, like Mozzarella, ricotta, sausage, Parmigiano Reggiano and extra-virgin olive oil.

Best-seller: Pizza Anna

1200 Pennsylvania Ave., Bridgeville
412/257-5150, cucina-bella.com


The Enrico Biscotti Cafe

It makes sense that, as an Italian bakery, Enrico Biscotti Café would care about its dough. Pie varieties range from the simple pepperoni to the white pizza with cranberries and blue cheese; some pizzas even feature ingredients from Enrico’s rooftop garden. For a balanced meal, consider grabbing a big salad or some beans and greens, too.

Note: This spot is only open for lunch Monday through Saturday (11 a.m.-3 p.m.).
  
Best-seller: Margherita

2022 Penn Ave., Strip District
412/281-2602, enricobiscotti.com


Edit Module

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

Pittsburgh's Top 10 in April

Pittsburgh's Top 10 in April

The 10 best things to do in April in Pittsburgh.
20 Great Biking & Hiking Trails in Western Pennsylvania

20 Great Biking & Hiking Trails in Western Pennsylvania

Each trail has been lovingly constructed and maintained, using old infrastructure to reconnect disparate communities.
A Superior Strategy? Kevin Sousa's Big Bet on Braddock

A Superior Strategy? Kevin Sousa's Big Bet on Braddock

Pittsburgh chef Kevin Sousa will draw on a fierce work ethic, community goodwill and faith in his own vision for Superior Motors, the progressive American spot he plans to open this year.
Getting Better Over Time: PNC Park at 15

Getting Better Over Time: PNC Park at 15

Adoration for PNC Park is near-universal. But would the park be the cherished baseball palace it is today if a few early proposals instead had become reality?
Edit ModuleShow Tags

The 412

Just Released: Trailer for Jake Gyllenhaal's New Movie Shot in Pittsburgh

Just Released: Trailer for Jake Gyllenhaal's New Movie Shot in Pittsburgh

The boxing drama "Southpaw" is set to arrive in theaters in late July.
Pittsburgh’s Billy Gardell Hosts ‘Monopoly’ Game Show

Pittsburgh’s Billy Gardell Hosts ‘Monopoly’ Game Show

The “Monopoly Millionaire’s Club” premieres this weekend.
Cutch Cuts the Locks

Cutch Cuts the Locks

The Pirates outfielder cut his hair for the first time in eight years.
Pens Honor Mike Lange for 40 Years of Unforgettable Play-by-Play

Pens Honor Mike Lange for 40 Years of Unforgettable Play-by-Play

How many of his classic calls can you recite?
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

Pittsburgh's Top 10 in April

Pittsburgh's Top 10 in April

The 10 best things to do in April in Pittsburgh.
20 Great Biking & Hiking Trails in Western Pennsylvania

20 Great Biking & Hiking Trails in Western Pennsylvania

Each trail has been lovingly constructed and maintained, using old infrastructure to reconnect disparate communities.
A Superior Strategy? Kevin Sousa's Big Bet on Braddock

A Superior Strategy? Kevin Sousa's Big Bet on Braddock

Pittsburgh chef Kevin Sousa will draw on a fierce work ethic, community goodwill and faith in his own vision for Superior Motors, the progressive American spot he plans to open this year.
Getting Better Over Time: PNC Park at 15

Getting Better Over Time: PNC Park at 15

Adoration for PNC Park is near-universal. But would the park be the cherished baseball palace it is today if a few early proposals instead had become reality?
PittGirl: Preparing for a World Series Toast

PittGirl: Preparing for a World Series Toast

Thanks to her husband believing in "happy wife, happy life," PittGirl has the perfect wine to celebrate the Pirates' ultimate victory.
Pittsburgh's Top 10 Things to Do in March

Pittsburgh's Top 10 Things to Do in March

Your 10 best bets for this month.
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module