2012 Best Restaurants: Readers' Poll Results

Featuring first, second and third-place winners as determined by thousands of reader-cast ballots and tabulated by Grossman Yanak & Ford LLP.





Salt of the Earth photo by Laura Petrilla

Al Fresco

➊Pusadee’s Garden
pusadeesgarden.com

➋Il Pizzaiolo
ilpizzaiolo.com

➌Andora Restaurant
andorarestaurant.com

American

➊Bistro 19
bistro19.com

➋Six Penn Kitchen
sixpennkitchen.com

➌Atria’s Restaurant and Tavern
atrias.com

Atmosphere/Ambiance

➊Eleven
bigburrito.com/eleven

➋LeMont
lemontpittsburgh.com

➌Dish Osteria and Bar
dishosteria.com

➌Isabela on Grandview
isabelaongrandview.com (tie)

Authentic Pittsburgh Fare

➊Primanti Bros.
primantibros.com

➋Fat Head’s Saloon
fatheads.com

➌Szmidt’s Old World Deli

Bakery

➊Oakmont Bakery
oakmontbakery.com

➋Priory Fine Pastries
prioryfinepastries.com

➌Prantl’s Bakery
prantlsbakery.com

Banquet Hall

➊Grand Hall at the Priory
pittsburghsgrandhall.com

➋Rivers Casino
theriverscasino.com

➌The Chadwick
chadwickevents.com

Best-Kept Secret

➊Kaleidoscope Cafe

➋Spadafora’s Bar & Restaurant
spadaforas.net

➋Valliant’s Diner
valliantsdiner.com

Breakfast

➊Pamela’s P&G Diner
pamelasdiner.com

➋Eat’n Park
eatnpark.com

➌DeLuca’s

Breathtaking View

➊LeMont
lemontpittsburgh.com

➋Isabela on Grandview
isabelaongrandview.com

➌Monterey Bay Fish Grotto
montereybayfishgrotto.com

Brunch

➊Grand Concourse
muer.com

➋Paris 66
paris66bistro.xbuild.com

➌Coca Cafe
cocacafe.net

 

Burger

➊Burgatory
burgatorybar.com

➋Alchemy N’ Ale
alchemynalepgh.com

➌BRGR Bar
brgrpgh.com

BYOB

➊Arpino Trattoria
arpinotrattoria.com

➋Avenue B
avenueb-pgh.com

➋Piccolo Forno
piccolo-forno.com

Catering Services

➊Parkhurst Event Catering
parkhursteventcatering.com

➋big Burrito Restaurant Group
bigburrito.com

➌The Taj Mahal Restaurant
tajmahalinc.com

Cheap Eats

➊Eat’n Park
eatnpark.com

➋Primanti Bros.
primantibros.com

➌Lulu’s Noodles
lulusnoodles.com

Chinese

➊Sesame Inn
sesameinn.com

➋China Palace
chinapalacepittsburgh.com

➌Jimmy Wan’s
jimmywans.com

Cocktails

➊Olive or Twist
olive-twist.com

➋Salt of the Earth
saltpgh.com

➌Andys Wine Bar
andyswinebar.com

Comfort Food

➊Bistro To Go & Co.
bistroandcompany.com

➋Meat & Potatoes
meatandpotatoespgh.com

➌Atria’s Restaurant and Tavern
atrias.com

Most Creative Menu

➊Salt of the Earth
saltpgh.com

➋Tamari
tamaripgh.com

➌Spoon
spoonpgh.com

 

Deli

➊Smallman Street Deli
smallmanstreetdeli.com

➋Boulevard Deli
boulevarddeli.com

➌Zuppa’s Delicatessen
zuppasdeli.com

Dessert

➊Gullifty’s
gulliftys.us

➋The Cheesecake Factory
thecheesecakefactory.com

➌SweetHouse Bake Shop
sweethousebakeshop.com

Diner

➊Pamela’s P&G Diner
pamelasdiner.com

➋Ritter’s Diner

➌Valliant’s Diner
valliantsdiner.com

Family-Friendly

➊Eat‘n Park
eatnpark.com

➋Red Robin
redrobin.com

➌Kings Family Restaurant
kingsfamily.com

French

➊Paris 66
paris66bistro.xbuild.com

➋Brasserie 33
brasserie33.com

➌Café Du Jour

German

➊Max’s Allegheny Tavern
maxsalleghenytavern.com

➋Hofbräuhaus Pittsburgh
hofbrauhauspittsburgh.com

➌Penn Brewery
pennbrew.com

Gluten-Friendly

➊Café Chocolade
cafechocolade.net

➋Gluuteny
gluuteny.com

➌Pasta Lorenzo
pastalorenzo.com

Happy-Hour Eats

➊Mad Mex
madmex.com

➋Andys Wine Bar
andyswinebar.com

➌Tamari
tamaripgh.com

Hotel Dining

➊Habitat
habitatrestaurant.com

➋Braddock’s American Brasserie
braddocksrestaurant.com

➌The Terrace Room at the Omni William Penn
omnihotels.com

Indian

➊The Taj Mahal Restaurant
tajmahalinc.com

➋Tamarind
tamarindpa.com

➌India Garden
indiagarden.net

 

Italian Non-Chain

➊Spadafora’s Bar & Restaurant
spadaforas.net

➋Angelo’s Restaurant
angelosrestaurant.com

➌Arpino Trattoria
arpinotrattoria.com

Japanese

➊Nakama Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar
eatatnakama.com

➋Little Tokyo
littletokyopittsburgh.com

➌Ichiban Hibachi Steakhouse
ichibanhibachisteakhouse.com

Korean

➊Sushi Kim
sushikim.com

➋Golden Pig

➌Green Pepper
greenpepperpgh.com

➌Korea Garden
koreagardenpa.com (tie)

Last Meal on Earth

➊Salt of the Earth
saltpgh.com

➋Ruth’s Chris Steak House
ruthschris.com

➌Eleven
bigburrito.com/eleven

Late-Night Fare

➊Primanti Bros.
primantibros.com

➋Eat‘n Park
eatnpark.com

➌Mad Mex
madmex.com

Latin

➊Seviche
seviche.com

➋Mallorca
mallorcarestaurant.com

➌Alma Pan-Latin Kitchen
almapgh.com

Local Coffee Shop

➊Coffee Tree Roasters
coffeetree.com

➋Crazy Mocha
crazymocha.com

➌Espresso a Mano
espressoamano.com

Locally Sourced Menu

➊Legume
legumebistro.com

➋Habitat
habitatrestaurant.com

➌Restaurant Echo
restaurantecho.com

Lunch Spot

➊Arpino Trattoria
arpinotrattoria.com

➋The Porch at Schenley
theporchatschenley.com

➌Habitat
habitatrestaurant.com

Mediterranean

➊Mediterrano
mediterranocuisine.com

➋Casbah
bigburrito.com/casbah

➌Aladdin’s Eatery
aladdinseatery.com

 

Mexican

➊Mad Mex
madmex.com

➋El Campesino
elcampesino.net

➌Emiliano’s
emilianos.net

Microbrewery

➊Church Brew Works
churchbrew.com

➋East End Brewing Co.
eastendbrewing.com

➌Penn Brewery
pennbrew.com

Middle Eastern

➊Aladdin’s Eatery
aladdinseatery.com

➋Ali Baba
alibabapittsburgh.com

➌Amel’s
amelsrestaurant.net

Most Romantic

➊Isabela on Grandview
isabelaongrandview.com

➋LeMont
lemontpittsburgh.com

➌Dish Osteria and Bar
dishosteria.com

➌Hyeholde
hyeholde.com (tie)

Pizza Non-Chain

➊Mineo’s Pizza House
mineospizza.com

➋Fiori’s Pizzaria
fiorispizzaria.com

➌Il Pizzaiolo
ilpizzaiolo.com

Polish

➊Bloomfield Bridge Tavern
bloomfieldbridgetavern.com

➋Pierogies Plus
pierogiesplus.com

➌S&D Polish Deli
sdpolishdeli.com

Pub

➊Alchemy N’ Ale
alchemynalepgh.com

➋Piper’s Pub
piperspub.com

➌Riley’s Pour House
rileyspourhouse.com

Seafood

➊Monterey Bay Fish Grotto
montereybayfishgrotto.com

➋Mitchell’s Fish Market
mitchellsfishmarket.com

➌Red Lobster
redlobster.com

 

Special Occasion

➊Eleven
bigburrito.com/eleven

➋Grand Concourse
muer.com

➌Monterey Bay Fish Grotto
montereybayfishgrotto.com

Sports Bar

➊Jerome Bettis Grille 36
jeromebettisgrille36.g3restaurants.com

➋Wheelhouse
theriverscasino.com/dining/wheelhouse

➌StonePepper’s Grill
stonepeppers.com

Steak

➊Ruth’s Chris Steak House
ruthschris.com

➋The Capital Grille
thecapitalgrille.com

➌Morton’s The Steakhouse
mortons.com

Sushi

➊Nakama Japanese Steakhouse and Sushi Bar
eatatnakama.com

➋Umi
bigburrito.com/umi

➋Tamari
tamaripgh.com

Tapas

➊Ibiza Tapas & Wine Bar
ibizatapasrestaurant.com

➋Seviche
seviche.com

➌Tamari
tamaripgh.com

Thai

➊Nicky’s Thai Kitchen
nickysthaikitchen.com

➋Smiling Banana Leaf
smilingbananaleaf.com

➌The Green Mango
thegreenmango.com

 

Theater Dining

➊Six Penn Kitchen
sixpennkitchen.com

➋Meat & Potatoes
meatandpotatoespgh.com

➌Braddock’s American Brasserie
braddocksrestaurant.com

Trendy

➊Salt of the Earth
saltpgh.com

➋Meat & Potatoes
meatandpotatoespgh.com

➌Spoon
spoonpgh.com

Vegetarian

➊Quiet Storm Vegetarian & Vegan Cafe
qspgh.com

➋Kaya
bigburrito.com/kaya

➌The Taj Mahal Restaurant
tajmahalinc.com

Vietnamese

➊Tram’s Kitchen

➋Vietnam’s Pho
vietnamspho.com

➌Pho Minh

Wait Staff

➊Bistro 19
bistro19.com

➊The Carlton Restaurant
thecarltonrestaurant.com (tie)

➌The Capital Grille
thecapitalgrille.com

Wine Bar

➊The Wine Loft
thewineloftpittsburgh.net

➋Toast! Kitchen & Wine Bar
toastpittsburgh.com

➌Sonoma Grille
thesonomagrille.com

Wine Selection

➊Sonoma Grille
thesonomagrille.com

➋Wooden Angel
wooden-angel.com

➌Eleven
bigburrito.com/eleven

➌Toast! Kitchen & Wine Bar
toastpittsburgh.com (tie)

Hot Reads

Top 10

Top 10

Here are the 10 best things to do in Pittsburgh this November.
Review: One Thirty One East

Review: One Thirty One East

Located in the southwest suburban community of Carnegie, One Thirty One East embodies the area’s renaissance.
Grow. Cook. Drink.: Maggie Meskey of Butcher and the Rye

Grow. Cook. Drink.: Maggie Meskey of Butcher and the Rye

The charismatic Maggie Meskey had tended bar for years before landing her gig at downtown bourbon haven Butcher and the Rye.
13 Bartenders You Should Know

13 Bartenders You Should Know

Get acquainted with this group of charming bar professionals working in various establishments around the city.

The 412

CMU’s Newest Campus-Life Venture Is Decidedly Low Tech

CMU’s Newest Campus-Life Venture Is Decidedly Low Tech

Check your laptop (and your textbook) at the door and stop by the Mindfulness Room for a little zen.
Your Guide to Putting Together a Costume in Less Than 24 Hours

Your Guide to Putting Together a Costume in Less Than 24 Hours

Follow these steps to assemble your best Halloween getup yet.
Could ‘Green Light-Go’ Eliminate the Pittsburgh Left?

Could ‘Green Light-Go’ Eliminate the Pittsburgh Left?

The state-sponsored program looks to add $75 million in traffic-signal upgrades throughout the city.
Google Dedicates Today’s Doodle to Jonas Salk

Google Dedicates Today’s Doodle to Jonas Salk

See a tribute to the late scientist each time you go to look up something today.

Hot Reads

Top 10

Top 10

Here are the 10 best things to do in Pittsburgh this November.
Review: One Thirty One East

Review: One Thirty One East

Located in the southwest suburban community of Carnegie, One Thirty One East embodies the area’s renaissance.
Grow. Cook. Drink.: Maggie Meskey of Butcher and the Rye

Grow. Cook. Drink.: Maggie Meskey of Butcher and the Rye

The charismatic Maggie Meskey had tended bar for years before landing her gig at downtown bourbon haven Butcher and the Rye.
12 Hot New Restaurants

12 Hot New Restaurants

A diverse crop of eateries caught our attention this year, so we’re highlighting some of our favorites.
Why Things Get Squirrely Near the Tunnels

Why Things Get Squirrely Near the Tunnels

PittGirl doesn't know why we say "warsh" — but she has figured out why we 'Burghers hit the brakes at the sight of the Squirrel Hill Tunnel.
13 Bartenders You Should Know

13 Bartenders You Should Know

Get acquainted with this group of charming bar professionals working in various establishments around the city.