Putting the Pirates’ 19-Straight Losing Seasons Into Perspective

From Bonds to McCutchen, from dial-up to 4G, from '92 to 2011, much has changed, yet one thing remains the same.


Photo by Uprooted Photographer

Whenever the Pirates clinch a losing season, I tend to go searching for a bit of perspective to remind myself just how long their losing streak has been intact. Here's what I came up with for the Pirates 19th consecutive losing season in 2011: the 2011 Pirates are now as far removed from the last winning Pirate team—the 1992 Buccos—as the '92 Pirates were from the 1973 Pirates. The 1973 Pirates were the first edition to take the field after the tragic death of Roberto Clemente. In broader (and slightly rougher) terms, Andrew McCutchen is as far removed from Barry Bonds as Barry Bonds was from Roberto Clemente.  

As someone born after the Pirates' last World Series title, this is staggering to consider. When I was growing up as a Pirates fan in the early ’90s, there was a VHS tape that I watched basically on repeat for a year about the first 100 years of team history—from the Pittsburgh Alleghenys to Honus Wagner to Pie Traynor to Ralph Kiner to Clemente to Willie Stargell to the sad 1980s Pirates. The video ended with Barry Bonds and Andy Van Slyke, promising better days ahead. To me, everyone in that video was a historical figure except the people at the very end. Now, those players I grew up with are very much historical figures to young Pirates fans growing up today.

Think of all the things that happened between 1974 and Sid Bream's slide. The Pirates won the National League East in 1974 and 1975, but failed to get to the World Series. They finished third in the East three years in a row after that, then won the World Series in 1979. Willie Stargell retired and was elected to the Hall of Fame. The Pirates struggled badly in the early 1980s, but then hired general manager Syd Thrift in 1985. Thrift made a whirlwind of moves between ’85 and ’88 that set the foundation for the club's return to prominence in 1990. Between 1990 and 1992, they won three more division titles and lost three heart-breaking playoff series.

In total, that's six playoff appearances and a World Series in 19 years, and one very successful rebuilding project. It’s not exactly the 1940s Yankees, but it’s a solid run that many franchises would kill for. Teams like the present Pittsburgh Pirates.

Here's what's happened since the Pirates' 1992 season ended in heartbreak: GM Ted Simmons resigned during the 1992 season, leaving Cam Bonifay to oversee the project to rebuild the club in the wake of the departures of Bonds, Bobby Bonilla, and Doug Drabek. The Pirates weren't completely terrible between 1993 and 1996, but the Orlando Merced/Jay Bell/Jeff King/Carlos Garcia/Denny Neagle Pirates were far from successful and so the Bucs cleaned house as that contingent neared free agency.

With Kevin McClatchy assuming ownership in 1996, he and Bonifay declared that they would be instituting a five-year plan to have the Pirates competitive by the time PNC Park opened in 2001. Except for decent runs in 1997 and 1999, this plan failed miserably. PNC Park opened on the day that Willie Stargell died and the Pirates christened it with their first 100-loss season since 1985. Bonifay was fired part way through the season and Dave Littlefield took the reins. Littlefield's tenure never even got off of the ground and he'll be best remembered for making one of the worst trades of the aughts, the deal that sent Aramis Ramirez and Kenny Lofton to the Cubs for a handful of beans that no one thought was magical, even in 2003.

Littlefield was fired and McClatchy was pushed out in 2007 and since then we've been in the Neal Huntington/Frank Coonelly era, which has seen a strengthening of the minor league system but precious little in the way of Major League results.

In total, that's zero winning seasons, zero playoff appearances, three failed rebuilding efforts, and one rebuild that the jury's still out on. The 1973-1992 Pirates look like the Dream Team in comparison.

In fact, besides the current World Series drought (32 years and counting), the Pirates have only had one stretch in franchise history in which they went longer than 19 years between World Series. That was between 1925 and 1960, a stretch that contained the only era in modern Pirate history even arguably worse than the one we're in now, nine losing seasons from 1949-1957 that included three straight 100-loss seasons (’52-’54).

It's unfair to lump the whole of the last 19 years on anyone involved with the current Pirates or the way they're run. Since 2007, they've been working on a long-term plan to change the franchise's fortunes that's different than anything that's been attempted since the losing streak started. But they haven't turned things around yet, and so the brunt of this unprecedented losing streak falls on the only thing that the current Pirates really have in common with the 1992 Pirates: the fans. That's why it was so exciting to see the Pirates hang in contention through the end of July, and that's why 2011 feels worse than 2010, even if the record is a better.

 

Pat Lackey is a frequent guest blogger for Pulling No Punches. You can find him at his own blog, Where Have You Gone, Andy Van Slyke? and on Twitter @whygavs.

Edit Module

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

Review: Salt of the Earth

Review: Salt of the Earth

Brandon Fisher is the latest chef behind Salt of the Earth’s modern-American dishes.
2014 Pittsburgher of the Year Award: The Fred Rogers Company

2014 Pittsburgher of the Year Award: The Fred Rogers Company

Sharing the DNA of the father of children’s television, the Fred Rogers Company reinvigorates a beloved legacy while creating new hit characters and content that help children to grow, giggle and learn.
Update: The McMutrie Sisters' Mission 5 Years After the Haiti Earthquake

Update: The McMutrie Sisters' Mission 5 Years After the Haiti Earthquake

Jamie and Ali McMutrie were PM's 2010 Pittsburghers of the Year after airlifting 54 youngsters to safety. Now, they have forged a relationship with a major global player to continue their work to prevent struggling Haitian families from surrendering children to orphanages.
PittGirl's New Year's Resolutions for Pittsburghers

PittGirl's New Year's Resolutions for Pittsburghers

Four ways to make the city even better in 2015.
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags

On the Blogs


Everything That's Awesome About Pittsburgh Today
Must-See: Pittsburgh's Holiday Displays

Must-See: Pittsburgh's Holiday Displays

Get yourself in the holiday spirit in just over a minute.

Comments


Pittsburgh, only cooler
The World-Famous Yinzer Gift Guide: 2014

The World-Famous Yinzer Gift Guide: 2014

You can't miss with a gift from PittGirl’s list of 13 'Burgh-related must-haves.

Comments


All the foodie news that's fit to blog
Broadening Pittsburgh's Meat Horizons

Broadening Pittsburgh's Meat Horizons

A partnership between a local couple and a local farmer has resulted in more pasture-raised lamb and pork being sold at the market.

Comments


Not just good stuff. Great stuff.
10 Best Lunch Spots That Won’t Bust Your Budget

10 Best Lunch Spots That Won’t Bust Your Budget

Come lunchtime, these Pittsburgh eateries serve food that's big on flavor and low on cost.

Comments


Bar Exam: OTB Bicycle Cafe North Park

Bar Exam: OTB Bicycle Cafe North Park

The northern outpost of the "bikes, burgers, beers" bar takes the Bar Exam.

Comments


The Perfect Homemade Gift: Drunken Pirouettes

The Perfect Homemade Gift: Drunken Pirouettes

Julia Erickson, co-founder of Barre, shares the recipe for a homemade energy snack, fueled with a touch of Wigle’s organic rye whiskey.

Comments


Style. Design. Goods. Hide your credit card.
Elf for Your Shelf

Elf for Your Shelf

Artist Ken Wagle draws on his Pennsylvania Dutch heritage to create unique carvings of the North Pole’s biggest elf — Santa.

Comments


This week's buzz from the PM editors
Last Call: Kennywood Holiday Lights

Last Call: Kennywood Holiday Lights

Make plans to enjoy the array of family-friendly activities and performances the park has to offer.

Comments


Award-winning sports commentary by Sean Conboy
R.I.P. Corporate Penguins, 2009-2014

R.I.P. Corporate Penguins, 2009-2014

Fire Bylsma? Fire Shero? The Penguins' problems run deeper.

Comments

Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags