Edit ModuleEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

He Wondered If Pittsburgh Could Survive a Disaster – And Then It Did

The reporter who researched and wrote a story about how Pittsburgh might respond to a disaster got the answer much sooner than he anticipated.



Embed from Getty Images

This is Not a Drill, Can Pittsburgh Survive a Disaster? began as a thought experiment. I was sitting in traffic on a snowy morning in January, listening to radio reporters dissect the Hawaiian missile scare. Though the chaos in Waikiki seemed a world away from Pittsburgh’s icy streets, I couldn’t help but wonder: How would Pittsburghers respond, collectively, if the unthinkable happened here?

Less than two weeks after the resulting article was published, we found out.

The massacre at the Tree of Life synagogue has shaken Pittsburgh in a way it hasn’t been shaken for decades. It’s been more than 80 years since the city grappled with tragedy on such a scale, with grieving family members and friends under the national spotlight’s fleeting glare. The “darkest day of Pittsburgh history,” as Mayor Bill Peduto has called it, will no doubt join the terrible ranks of Pittsburgh’s worst disasters.

In the days following the slaughter, I found myself looking back at what I’d learned while researching this piece — namely, how the city responded to another great calamity, the St. Patrick’s Day Flood of 1936.

Newspapers from the time are full of stories about Pittsburghers coming together. “Apparently the railroads had carried out of town all the grouchy people. There weren’t any around,” wrote one reporter. A store owner gave away a thousand mattresses and a thousand blankets, wrote another. When a reporter named Charles M. Pooler — who was navigating Downtown via rowboat — was drawn toward a hotel by the sound of a choir, he climbed through a second-story window to find 600 stranded strangers singing “River, Stay ‘Way from My Door.”

That scene was on my mind as I stood in Squirrel Hill 82 years later, watching more than a thousand people sing Hebrew hymns as they marched and mourned. The moment was just one of many modern parallels to Pittsburgh’s flood response: Within hours of the shooting, donors jammed the city’s blood banks. High school students convened a candlelight vigil. Museums opened their doors for free, businesses gave their proceeds to charity, and the city’s Muslim community raised hundreds of thousands of dollars — enough to pay for the funerals of each of the 11 people murdered. The list goes on and on, and will surely expand during the coming weeks and months.

These gestures of goodwill have been widely celebrated, and rightfully so. We’ll no longer wonder how Pittsburghers respond to catastrophe — we’ve shown each other, and the world, what we’re willing to do.

But a larger question looms. Will we channel our anger, our sadness and our generosity into real, lasting change? Or will we fall back on our old ways, relying instead on the oversimplified narrative of Pittsburgh as a model of inclusivity and neighborly love — a narrative which held true in this instance, but which has failed people and communities on the margins from the city’s very beginning?

If we’re going to accomplish the former, we have a lot of work to do.

But anything less would be the biggest disaster of all.

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module

Edit Module Edit ModuleShow TagsEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit ModuleShow Tags

The Latest

First-Of-Its-Kind Flower Truck Blooms in Pittsburgh

Customers are able to pick their own bouquet from the collection of fresh stems aboard Victoria Miess's mobile, mint green mini-truck.

All the County Fairs Happening This Summer in Western PA

Mark your calendars. There are 35 county fairs in western Pennsylvania this summer.

2019 Pittsburgh Area Fireworks: Where & When to Watch Them

This booming list of fireworks displays can help you get your fill of patriotism during the long holiday week.

What to Do with an Old Bank? Redecorate with Part of a Plane

The former PNC Bank in West View is now a community resource center with some very unique features.

The 400-Word Review: The Last Black Man in San Francisco

This arresting debut feature about displacement by the Bay is one of the year's best films.

Songs of Steel for a Summer in Pittsburgh

Love PGH Music Month has formed just in time for a summer filled with great shows.

You Could Be in a Viola Davis and Chadwick Boseman Film

Want to be in a movie alongside some top celebrities? This is your chance!

Food, Beer and Games at the Crafty Jackalope

The popular Bridgeville bar serves its neighborhood well.

Can't Miss Concerts in Pittsburgh in July

This month's lineup includes Belle and Sebastian, Kurt Vile and actor-turned-rockstar Billy Bob Thornton and his band The Boxmasters.

Recommended Pittsburgh Eating: 3 Recent Dishes I Loved

PM dining critic Hal B. Klein is eating seasonal salads, sushi and sandwiches.

Transit May Improve Thanks to New Technology

Public transit users may luck out if Port Authority’s wristband ticketing service experiment goes well.

The 400-Word Review: Toy Story 4

Pixar's signature series comes up with an enjoyable fourth chapter. Just don't set your expectations too high.

The Latest Restaurant Openings In Pittsburgh

We say hello to three new Galley Group concepts, plus Con Alma, Over Eden and Inner Groove Brewing.

The Business of Building Cookie Table Bridges

After her cookie table bridges proved to be a hit at her own wedding, a Pittsburgh bride has taken her idea to the next level.

All You Need to Know About Fireworks in Pennsylvania

With new state fireworks laws in place, Pennsylvanians will get a little more freedom to celebrate this Fourth of July.
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags


All the County Fairs Happening This Summer in Western PA

All the County Fairs Happening This Summer in Western PA

Mark your calendars. There are 35 county fairs in western Pennsylvania this summer.

Comments

2019 Pittsburgh Area Fireworks: Where & When to Watch Them

2019 Pittsburgh Area Fireworks: Where & When to Watch Them

This booming list of fireworks displays can help you get your fill of patriotism during the long holiday week.

Comments


All the foodie news that's fit to blog
Recommended Pittsburgh Eating: 3 Recent Dishes I Loved

Recommended Pittsburgh Eating: 3 Recent Dishes I Loved

PM dining critic Hal B. Klein is eating seasonal salads, sushi and sandwiches.

Comments

The Latest Restaurant Openings In Pittsburgh

The Latest Restaurant Openings In Pittsburgh

We say hello to three new Galley Group concepts, plus Con Alma, Over Eden and Inner Groove Brewing.

Comments


Not just good stuff. Great stuff.
5 Best Spots to Hang Out with Your Dog

5 Best Spots to Hang Out with Your Dog

For those who can’t stand the idea of leaving their dogs home alone on a beautiful day, these dog-friendly stores, restaurants and bars in the Pittsburgh area welcome humans and canines alike.

Comments

5 Races You (Yes, You) Can Run This Year

5 Races You (Yes, You) Can Run This Year

Even novice runners can work their way up to these fun and (mildly) challenging races.

Comments


Food, Beer and Games at the Crafty Jackalope

Food, Beer and Games at the Crafty Jackalope

The popular Bridgeville bar serves its neighborhood well.

Comments

In a Crowded City for Concerts, Rivers Casino Steps Up

In a Crowded City for Concerts, Rivers Casino Steps Up

The casino's new Events Center proves itself more than worthy of competing for big-name acts.

Comments


Mike Prisuta's Sports Section

A weekly look at the games people are playing and the people who are playing them.
DeCastro’s Preferred Order: Fries with That, Hold the Drama

DeCastro’s Preferred Order: Fries with That, Hold the Drama

The Steelers have emerged from their offseason sessions confident they’re capable of playing better. They also maintain a new atmosphere and culture have been established. But they won’t know for certain until they actually start playing.

Comments

Pittsburgh Steelers' No. 1 Pick Makes a Lasting First Impression

Pittsburgh Steelers' No. 1 Pick Makes a Lasting First Impression

Devin Bush will still have much to prove once the pads come on and the hitting commences. But the presence and purpose he brought to OTAs justified the hype on draft day.

Comments


The movies that are playing in Pittsburgh –– and, more importantly, whether or not they're worth your time.
The 400-Word Review: The Last Black Man in San Francisco

The 400-Word Review: The Last Black Man in San Francisco

This arresting debut feature about displacement by the Bay is one of the year's best films.

Comments

The 400-Word Review: Toy Story 4

The 400-Word Review: Toy Story 4

Pixar's signature series comes up with an enjoyable fourth chapter. Just don't set your expectations too high.

Comments


Everything you need to know about getting married in Pittsburgh today.
The Business of Building Cookie Table Bridges

The Business of Building Cookie Table Bridges

After her cookie table bridges proved to be a hit at her own wedding, a Pittsburgh bride has taken her idea to the next level.

Comments

The Most Popular Wedding Trends of Summer 2019

The Most Popular Wedding Trends of Summer 2019

Romantic bistro lights and balloon arrangements? Yes please.

Comments


Weekly inspiration for your home from the editors of Pittsburgh Magazine
First-Of-Its-Kind Flower Truck Blooms in Pittsburgh

First-Of-Its-Kind Flower Truck Blooms in Pittsburgh

Customers are able to pick their own bouquet from the collection of fresh stems aboard Victoria Miess's mobile, mint green mini-truck.

Comments

 PPG Paints Singin' the Blues for 2020 Color of the Year

PPG Paints Singin' the Blues for 2020 Color of the Year

Meant to offer relief from the anxieties of today’s fast-paced lifestyle, Chinese Porcelain is a mix of cobalt and ink blue. Here’s why you can expect to see more of it in the coming year.

Comments