5 Tough Decisions the Pirates Need to Make to Reach the World Series

Yesterday’s win proved that the Pirates can compete with any team in the postseason. But they’re going to need to address a few things to stick around.




Photo Courtesy Pittsburgh Pirates/Dave Arrigo

 

You’re forgiven if you doubted the Pirates’ ability to go deep into October this year. A young, untested team playing postseason baseball for the first time is likely to falter, no matter how much mojo it has floating above its home yard.
 

But the last two games — yesterday’s especially — demonstrated that the Pirates are poised to make a serious run. The Bucs have outplayed the Reds once and the Cardinals — a more experienced and probably more loaded club — twice. With the exception of Thursday’s one-man meltdown in St. Louis, the Pirates have taken care of business efficiently and decisively so far this month.
 

Nine more wins are required for a championship, however, and they’re only going to be tougher to grab. While the roster has been mostly effective through a week of postseason play, there are still questions that the Pirates should address (or at least discuss) to lock up a win in the NLCS and a shot at the pennant.
 


1. Should Justin Morneau continue to bat after McCutchen?
There’s little controversy in putting a former American League MVP with power and plate discipline in the cleanup spot. But Morneau, while hitting a respectable 5-for-17 in the postseason, has yet to record an RBI — despite McCutchen’s seven hits and five walks. Cutch has been on base for Morneau fully two-thirds of the time (his OBP is .667, leading every player still competing). It’s tough to shake up a lineup that’s working, and pitchers are still dancing around Morneau a bit. Still, I’d love to get the hot bats of Russell Martin or Marlon Byrd behind the MVP candidate and see what happens.
 

2. Should Neil Walker be benched?
Walker is now batting 0-for-13 in the NLDS. He hasn’t recorded a walk, and he’s struck out three times. Since going 2-for-5 with an RBI in the Wild Card game, he’s been a black hole. The Pirates’ depth — such as it is — is in the outfield, not the infield, and there’s not a natural solution if Walker leaves the lineup. But if he started 0-for-3 today, I’d think about putting Josh Harrison in there — or trotting both Jordy Mercer and Clint Barmes out, with Mercer at second. You’d hate to disrupt the feel-good story of the kid who grew up in Pittsburgh taking the Bucs back to the playoffs. But it’s a very bad time for a slump.
 

3. Should Mark Melancon be shut down?
I’ll answer this one for ’em — yes. Melancon was lights-out for much of the season, and he spent a stretch as one of the most dominant relievers in the game. That stretch is over. His blown saves in September may have single-handedly knocked the Pirates out of an N.L. Central title, and the moonshot he allowed to (the admittedly unstoppable) Carlos Beltran yesterday could’ve led to serious trouble. The rest of the Shark Tank has been too good to keep trotting out a shaky Melancon in the eighth.
 

4. Who should be pinch-hitting?
The Pirates have not recorded a pinch hit so far in the NLDS. Not necessarily a coincidence: Garrett Jones hasn’t had an at-bat. Jones was shaky at best during the regular season, but given his experience and power, I’d feel more comfortable with him trying for a clutch double (or, for that matter, a moonshot into the river) than the likes of Gaby Sanchez or Mercer. I wouldn’t get cute with these decisions; Jones has 15 HRs and 25 RBIs against right-handed pitchers this year. He’s your pinch-hitter against them. Against lefties, I’m not sure. But the Pirates should have a plan, and that plan probably shouldn’t involve the perennially disappointing Gaby Sanchez, who grounded into a double play yesterday.
 

5. What of A.J. Burnett?
Hopefully this is a short-term dilemma. The Pirates should decide, if only internally, that A.J. Burnett will start game 1 of the NLCS — which means that Gerrit Cole would start a potential NLDS game 5 Wednesday in St. Louis. Burnett is an average pitcher on the road — this year, 5-7 with a 4.22 ERA — but a disastrous one at Busch Stadium, where he posted an 8.10 ERA in the regular season. The Cards, as a club, posted a .941 OPS against Burnett at home. We all saw Thursday’s result. Simply put: If A.J. Burnett starts on Wednesday against St. Louis, the Pirates probably aren’t moving on. So it’ll have to be Cole if Wednesday’s game happens; hopefully the Dodgers will beat the Braves and Burnett can take the mound this weekend at Dodger Stadium, where he did well in one appearance earlier this year.
 

These are all, obviously, those clichéd “good problems to have.” We’re in the postseason debating details while Pedro, Liriano, McCutchen and Martin win playoff games for the Pittsburgh Pirates. After yesterday, it looks like they’re poised to win quite a few more.

 

Sean Collier is an associate editor at Pittsburgh Magazine. He'll be guest-blogging the Pirates’ postseason run for Pulling No Punches. Follow him on Twitter @seancollierpgh.



 

Edit Module

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

This Restless Pair are Pittsburgh Restaurateurs of the Year

This Restless Pair are Pittsburgh Restaurateurs of the Year

Together, Richard DeShantz and Tolga Sevdik of the Richard DeShantz Restaurant Group form the Pittsburgh restaurant world's most dynamic duo.
Best Restaurants in Pittsburgh in 2019

Best Restaurants in Pittsburgh in 2019

Our annual roundup of Pittsburgh's Best Restaurants covers a lot of ground. The list of 30 includes everything from fine dining at a resort hotel to a scrappy, farm-to-table breakfast and lunch counter in Bloomfield.
When I Have a Craving for a Specific Dish

When I Have a Craving for a Specific Dish

Here are a few Pittsburgh restaurants we didn’t include on the annual Best Restaurants list that our dining critic loves to visit when he's craving something specific.
How Pittsburgh's Homeless Teens Escape the Mean Streets

How Pittsburgh's Homeless Teens Escape the Mean Streets

For homeless Youth, living on the street can end up being worse than what they’re running from. Gaining their trust and guiding them to safety is a long and painful process, but local agencies are making progress.
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags


What Are You Doing to be Like Mister Rogers on 1-4-3 Day?

What Are You Doing to be Like Mister Rogers on 1-4-3 Day?

Pennsylvania names May 23 as 1-4-3 Day to celebrate its favorite neighbor.

Comments

A Slice of Pizza Kept Sean McDowell Going in the Early Days

A Slice of Pizza Kept Sean McDowell Going in the Early Days

After 41 years in the business, the legendary rock DJ on WDVE has announced his retirement.

Comments


All the foodie news that's fit to blog
Sharing Knives Grows into Sharing Farms

Sharing Knives Grows into Sharing Farms

For its third season, the collaborative dinner series at Ace Hotel will celebrate the region’s growers.

Comments

A Look at the Latest Restaurant Openings in Pittsburgh

A Look at the Latest Restaurant Openings in Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh says hello (again) to Dish Osteria, Cinderlands Warehouse, Pizzeria Davide and more.

Comments


Not just good stuff. Great stuff.
5 Best Spots to Hang Out with Your Dog

5 Best Spots to Hang Out with Your Dog

For those who can’t stand the idea of leaving their dogs home alone on a beautiful day, these dog-friendly stores, restaurants and bars in the Pittsburgh area welcome humans and canines alike.

Comments

5 Races You (Yes, You) Can Run This Year

5 Races You (Yes, You) Can Run This Year

Even novice runners can work their way up to these fun and (mildly) challenging races.

Comments


The Funhouse at Mr. Smalls is a Treasure

The Funhouse at Mr. Smalls is a Treasure

The small, second venue above the Millvale hall is one of the city's best rooms for live music.

Comments

Unleash Your Inner Pinball Wizard at Kickback

Unleash Your Inner Pinball Wizard at Kickback

The Lawrenceville pinball cafe offers new and classic games for you to play solo, or (as we were surprised to learn) in competition with a friend.

Comments


Mike Prisuta's Sports Section

A weekly look at the games people are playing and the people who are playing them.
Pirates’ First Quarter Record Defies Logic if Not Description

Pirates’ First Quarter Record Defies Logic if Not Description

The 21-19 record the Bucs took to San Diego doesn’t add up given all they’ve had to overcome. Perhaps there’s more to this team than meets the eye.

Comments

Steelers' Rookie Impressions Destined to Excite If Not Convince

Steelers' Rookie Impressions Destined to Excite If Not Convince

“Football in shorts” won't solve the Steelers' kicking woes, but for a team on the rebound, the rookie workouts are an opportunity to take another step in the right direction.

Comments


The movies that are playing in Pittsburgh –– and, more importantly, whether or not they're worth your time.
The 400-Word Review: Aladdin

The 400-Word Review: Aladdin

Disney's live-action remake of the '90s hit stars Will Smith as the iconic Genie.

Comments

The 400-Word Review: John Wick: Chapter 3 — Parabellum

The 400-Word Review: John Wick: Chapter 3 — Parabellum

Keanu Reeves returns, and Halle Berry arrives, as the action series broadens its scope.

Comments


Everything you need to know about getting married in Pittsburgh today.
This Wedding Had a Guest List Unlike Any Other

This Wedding Had a Guest List Unlike Any Other

Brendan Renne and Thais Canedo wanted a penguin at their wedding. They ended up with a menagerie.

Comments

You’ll #ShalieveInLove After Seeing Ryan Shazier's Wedding Photos

You’ll #ShalieveInLove After Seeing Ryan Shazier's Wedding Photos

Pittsburgh Steeler Ryan Shazier danced at his wedding Friday 18 months after a serious spinal injury.

Comments


Weekly inspiration for your home from the editors of Pittsburgh Magazine
New Tour Gives Insider Look at Pittsburgh’s Ethnic Neighborhoods

New Tour Gives Insider Look at Pittsburgh’s Ethnic Neighborhoods

With stops in Bloomfield and Polish Hill, the event from DOORS OPEN Pittsburgh celebrates the contributions immigrants made when they settled here more than a century ago.

Comments

Three North Side Garden Tours (And One on the South Side) You'll Want to Explore

Three North Side Garden Tours (And One on the South Side) You'll Want to Explore

Here’s your chance to explore some the city’s most beautiful historic (and new) homes and outdoor spaces.

Comments

Edit ModuleEdit ModuleShow Tags