Edit ModuleEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Rockaway Pizzeria in White Oak Will Expand This Summer

The New York style pizzeria also will pop up at Pittsburgh's Spring Hill Brewing starting next month.

photo by laura petrilla


One of my favorite Pittsburgh-area pizza joints is set to expand early this summer. Rockaway Pizzeria, Josh Sickels’ White Oak ode to the great pies of the New York City borough of Queens, will move from its current location by mid-July. “We’re literally moving right next door,” says Sickels.

He’s in the process of finalizing permits to overhaul the interior of a neighboring medical office into a what will become a substantial, dine-in restaurant. “It’s just like sardines in a can here right now,” Sickels says of his 800-square-foot space, which he opened in early 2017.

To that end, his new location will have a significantly bigger kitchen, a second oven and ample storage space, which is something that’s lacking in the current set-up. More importantly, he’ll have seating for somewhere between 40 to 60 people (depending on the final layout). Sickels says he does a robust pick-up operation but that there is high demand for dine-in restaurants in the suburb of White Oak. Opening a sit-down restaurant also is a relief to people like myself, who find themselves eating slices in their car on the way to hauling a pie (or two) that’s worth driving for back to the city.

Look for an expanded menu, which, in addition to the praiseworthy Queens pies, will include Sicilian-style pizza, salads, hoagies and a few classic pizzeria pasta dishes such as baked ziti.

In the meantime, there’s some good news for Pittsburghers who don’t want to drive to White Oak or wait for the new space — starting on May 5, Sickels will have a weekly Sunday residency from 3 p.m. to 8 p.m. at Spring Hill Brewing. He plans on serving slices and pies with limited toppings.

Sickels quietly started making pies there a few weeks ago so that he could adjust the composition of his dough to fit the location. He’s using Bakers Pride P-44 electric oven in Spring Hill; he uses a Bakers Pride Y600 gas oven in White Oak. “I’ve been doing it for my own sake to figure out how the oven works. Electric and gas are a little different, especially in that the electric oven has rods that heat up at the top. That changes the way the pizza bakes, so I have to be mindful of the hydration of my dough,” he says.

1955 Lincoln Way, White Oak; 412/896-8458, rockawaypizzeria.com

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module

Edit Module Edit ModuleShow TagsEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags

The Latest

New Smallman Galley Cocktail Menu Pays Homage to The Royal Tenenbaums

The Strip District food hall's late-summer drinks menu riffs on the Wes Anderson cult classic.

What's Your Favorite Happy Hour?

After Dark wants to know about your preferred spot for after-work drinks and deals.

The 400-Word Review: Good Boys

This raunchy comedy isn't just funny — it's surprisingly sweet.

#Shalieve in Love: An Exclusive Look at the Shaziers' Wedding

Ryan Shazier and wife Michelle Rodriguez never lost faith that they’d get their dream day. A year and a half after the Steelers linebacker suffered a severe spinal injury, he danced at his wedding.

11 Real Pittsburgh Weddings

Chosen from more than 70 submissions, these 11 couples celebrated with lots of personal touches at local venues. We share all of the details that got them to “I Do.”

Coach Mike Tomlin Confronts Sorrow from the Heart

The Steelers’ head coach dug deep while leading his team through its grief over the loss of beloved assistant coach Darryl Drake. The words were hard to find but Tomlin found them while revealing a side of himself the fans and media don’t always see.

Recommended Pittsburgh Eating: 4 Recent Dishes I Loved

PM Dining Critic Hal B. Klein says fried chicken, sour cherry soup, longevity noodles and garden-fresh Italian cooking have his attention this month.

Sandcastle's New Water Slide Promises a Wild Ride

The Homestead water park's new slide will send riders free falling at 26-feet-per second.

Cookie Table Contest Winners and Runners Up: A Taste of Pittsburgh

Cookie tables are wonderful things in and of themselves, but more and more couples choose to go above and beyond.

Get a Sneak Peek at Homes About to Hit the Market

Launched by North Hills resident Wendy Gilch, Selling Later is a new online community that allows future home sellers and prospective home buyers to connect — before the house is listed.

History Made in a Big Pittsburgh Way

A local organization has established a world record for the largest wedding cookie table, and we've got the pictures to prove it.

Giant Holiday Light Display Coming to Pittsburgh

What makes this display different is that it's all indoors.

PM on KD: Golden Anniversaries

Pittsburgh Magazine editor Brian Hyslop appeared on KDKA's Pittsburgh Today Live to discuss our August issue feature story on six important dates from the year of our founding — 1969.

What Millennials Want to See on Screen

"Reclaimed Roles," a photo series by local photographer Joe Lowrey and creative director Cat Burton, imagines what iconic films could look like with more diverse leads.

Steelers Rookie Getting His Ducks in a Row

Off-the-radar, out-of-nowhere quarterback candidate Devlin Hodges is making a name for himself at Saint Vincent College. Can the NFL really be his true calling?