A Cut Above: Primo Pizza Honorable Mentions

After compiling our list of 25 great pies, we kept eating, eventually concluding that these six spots also serve noteworthy pies.





Photo by Heather Mull
 

While discussing and planning our pizza feature, it was hard to not crave a slice (or two … or three). After weeks of deliberation, our restaurant critic, Valentina, agreed with us that the final list of 25 spots was stellar. But in a city chock-full of fantastic shops and eateries that dish out the cheesiest, sauciest pies, we didn’t think we could (or should) just stop at 25. Why not commend some more on their top-notch efforts to satisfy our hunger (and cravings)? Here’s our list of a half-dozen other fabulous spots — places that also dish out pies that are a cut above.
 

Vincent’s Pizza Park
Sure, we’re all continuing to mourn the loss of the Vincent’s on Ardmore Boulevard. But over in Plum and Irwin, the Vinnie Pie is still being served up, large and simple (with just three ingredients) — the way we like it. Slightly greasy (and oh-so-cheesy), the enormous pies are best eaten with utensils. Come hungry; leave happy.

1910 New Texas Road, Plum, 724/733-7377; 8871 Route 30, Irwin, 724/864-7059



Gluuteny
Known for sweet treats like whoopie pies and snickerdoodles, Gluuteny can draw a crowd. But instead of just picking up gluten- and casein-free treats next time you visit, why not get something savory, too — like the (soy-free) vegan pizza? The 12-inch round pie, topped with vegan cheese, is pulled straight from the oven and handed to hungry customers. It’s feel-good pizza — after all, how could you feel guilty after devouring a few slices of a fresh pie with only plant-based ingredients? Exactly.
1923 Murray Ave., Squirrel Hill; 412/521-4890, gluuteny.com



Papa J’s
Most locals know that Papa J’s Centro, situated along the busy Boulevard of the Allies, is a haunted yet cozy joint. But don’t let that outshine the cuisine, for the Italian offerings — namely the pizza — deserve some attention. Specialties range from the delectable barbecue-chicken pizza to the classic American-Italian style Margherita. With six- and eight-cut options, you’re bound to get the right amount of slices (but leftovers are great, too). Papa J’s sister establishment, the Ristorante, dishes out the same fare over in Carnegie.

Centro: Boulevard of the Allies and Market Street, downtown, 412/391-7272; Ristorante: Main Street and Broadway, Carnegie, 412/479-7272, papajs.com



Pietro’s Pizzaria
What can we say? For the past decade, the old-school approach of Pietro Servagno (plus his wife and two sons) has impressed us each time we’ve had a hankering for Italian-style pizza. On a drizzly weeknight, when there’s not much time to cook (or anything decent, for that matter), the Servagno crew pulls through with homemade traditional pies, which are topped with garden-fresh veggies in the summer. Not in the mood to pick up your pie? Pietro’s delivers (yes, that was music to our ears, too). Either way, you’re gonna love it.

719 W. Ingomar Road, McCandless; 412/364-9799



Pi Coal Fired
Yes, we have traditional and wood-fired pies here in Pittsburgh. But many don’t know that coal-fired is also an option. Nestled in a partly converted nightlife lounge, Pi is serious about its Neapolitan-style pizzas. Having an undeniable coal flavor, the thin-crust pizzas are large enough to eat on your own if you’re really hungry — but it’s more fun to share more than one between friends. Solid picks include the flavorful Diavola, crowned with spicy Italian salami, and the classic Margherita — or the create-your-own option works just as well.

1707 E. Carson St., South Side; 412/431-5095, picoalfired.com



Luciano’s
It may not look like much on the outside, but Luciano’s truly delivers. With a list of hand-tossed pies ranging from traditional pepperoni to Greek to Florentine, there’s something for everyone. Comprising homemade dough and an abundance of cheese, the slices are great alone or with cheese sticks and dipping sauce. Be sure to pick up a six-pack with your order; you might as well wash down your grub the old-fashioned way.

1030 Clifton Road, Bethel Park; 412/835-1733, lucianosbethel.com

Did we still miss your favorite spot? Tell us about it below in the comments section.

 

Edit Module

Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

50 Most Powerful People in Pittsburgh

50 Most Powerful People in Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh Magazine consulted dozens of power brokers and behind-the-scene players to determine and rank the 50 individuals who, in Pittsburgh, make things happen.
15 of Pittsburgh's Future Power Brokers

15 of Pittsburgh's Future Power Brokers

According to the region's behind-the-scene players, these individuals are some of the city's rising stars.
Aggressive and Adaptable: Pirates' All-Star Gerrit Cole

Aggressive and Adaptable: Pirates' All-Star Gerrit Cole

Entering into the final weeks of the 2015 regular season, pitcher Gerrit Cole has emerged as the Pirates’ ace.
At täkō - Terrific Tacos and Tequila Are Just The Beginning

At täkō - Terrific Tacos and Tequila Are Just The Beginning

Richard DeShantz and Tolga Sevdik strike again with täkō, their taco-centric downtown eatery with an extensive tequila selection.
Edit ModuleShow Tags

The 412

Verses Koufax and the Babe - Clemente Wins in a Rout

Verses Koufax and the Babe - Clemente Wins in a Rout

It was no contest among voters asked to choose which portrait among the three baseball greats should hang in the Smithsonian.
See Now: Trailer for Will Smith's "Concussion" Drama

See Now: Trailer for Will Smith's "Concussion" Drama

Shot and set in Pittsburgh, the film stars Will Smith as Dr. Bennet Omalu, the forensic pathologist who first discovered CTE in the brain of former Pittsburgh Steelers center Mike Webster in 2002.
Watch: New Trailer for Christmas Comedy Shot in Pittsburgh

Watch: New Trailer for Christmas Comedy Shot in Pittsburgh

Winter weather presented a number of challenges for the big-name cast led by Diane Keaton, John Goodman and Olivia Wilde.
Commuting Toll: How Much Do We Waste Stuck in Traffic?

Commuting Toll: How Much Do We Waste Stuck in Traffic?

Pittsburgh gridlock not only frays nerves — it dings the wallet.
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Hot Reads

50 Most Powerful People in Pittsburgh

50 Most Powerful People in Pittsburgh

Pittsburgh Magazine consulted dozens of power brokers and behind-the-scene players to determine and rank the 50 individuals who, in Pittsburgh, make things happen.
15 of Pittsburgh's Future Power Brokers

15 of Pittsburgh's Future Power Brokers

According to the region's behind-the-scene players, these individuals are some of the city's rising stars.
Aggressive and Adaptable: Pirates' All-Star Gerrit Cole

Aggressive and Adaptable: Pirates' All-Star Gerrit Cole

Entering into the final weeks of the 2015 regular season, pitcher Gerrit Cole has emerged as the Pirates’ ace.
At täkō - Terrific Tacos and Tequila Are Just The Beginning

At täkō - Terrific Tacos and Tequila Are Just The Beginning

Richard DeShantz and Tolga Sevdik strike again with täkō, their taco-centric downtown eatery with an extensive tequila selection.
 A Sign That This Time, It's Good to Part with the Past

A Sign That This Time, It's Good to Part with the Past

Pitt Girl explains her change of heart on what should be done with the large, decaying billboard on Mount Washington.
Oh, the Humanities - Can They be Saved?

Oh, the Humanities - Can They be Saved?

Locally and nationally, college and university students are flocking to programs they perceive to be pathways to jobs while they forego studies of languages, history, art and philosophy. But at what cost?
Edit ModuleShow Tags Edit Module