Beer Hear!

The "Should I Drink That?" podcast brings the joy of craft beers to listeners' ears.



Brad Brown and Douglas Derda of "Should I Drink That?"

Photo by Justin Bevilacqua

For St. Patrick’s Day and every day throughout the year, a puzzle perplexes the palates of beer-loving Pittsburghers: “Should I drink that?” Fortunately, two brew-wise guys provide the answer with an entertaining, educational podcast.

Douglas Derda (a.k.a. Father Spoon) and Brad Brown (a.k.a. sickpuppy) met in 1998 while working at FORE Systems. They discovered a mutual love of “craft beers,” which are lesser-known beers from microbreweries.

In March 2006 they decided to start sharing their knowledge and vast, expansive, selfless beer-drinking experience with anyone who would listen. More than 600,000 downloads later, “Should I Drink That?” (or, as it is known, SIDT) has garnered what Derda calls “a passionate, unique group of rabid fans, from beginners to hard-core aficionados, who cheer us when we’re right and let us have it when we’re wrong.”

Fans aren’t the only ones who recognize SIDT’s quality. The show was a finalist for two national podcast awards and was featured in DRAFT Magazine, a leading consumer beer journal.

It’s fun listening to SIDT and illuminating to hear about the array of craft-beer varieties and flavors on the market. In each episode the guys talk about several beers, comparing the characteristics of each and giving their (sometimes conflicting) opinions. Some of their most popular episodes are live events taped at beer festivals (where they interview brewery representatives) or at beer samplings at local watering holes where they can interact with their lively fans.

Like all podcasters, Derda and Brown labor for love—they’re true craft-beer evangelists. “We want people to know there are great tastes out there, beyond the typical Bud, Coors and Miller they associate with beer.” Many of the best craft beers are from western Pennsylvania, which, says Derda, “is a craft-beer destination.”

Not a day goes by, Derda reports, that he and Brown don’t get asked for a beer recommendation. “I’ll ask what they drink now, what flavors they typically like—sweet, bitter, tart? I’ll find out if they want something with high alcohol content or a ‘session beer,’ something with low alcohol. We can always find something for them to enjoy.”

A big hit on the show is the SIDT “Drunk Dial Hotline.” Knowing that some people tend to make regrettable phone calls to girlfriends, bosses and others while under the influence, Derda and Brown set up a hotline and invited listeners to drunk dial them instead. The results, Derda says, can be hilarious. Other highlights are their “chug challenge” videos and reactions to less-than-stellar brews. (Their motto, in fact, is, “Even if it’s crap, we drink it so you don’t have to.”)

But for all the fun, Derda and Brown take their beers and their relationship with their fans seriously. One of the best reactions was from a soldier from Pittsburgh stationed in Iraq. “He said listening to us, even just hearing our accent, reminded him of home and helped get him through. We were really touched by that,” Derda says.

To learn more, listen to episodes and watch videos, visit shouldidrinkthat.com.

Hot Reads

Top 10

Top 10

Your 10 best bets for October.
Made in Pittsburgh

Made in Pittsburgh

The city of steel always has been known for its industry – what we make. Today, that defining characteristic expands beyond manufacturing into every aspect of modern life.
Ed Piskor is Pittsburgh's Hip-Hop Historian

Ed Piskor is Pittsburgh's Hip-Hop Historian

Comic-book artist Ed Piskor continues to win critical acclaim and international fame with his “Hip Hop Family Tree” series of graphic novels.
Review: Istanbul Sofra

Review: Istanbul Sofra

Head to Istanbul Sofra, one of Regent Square’s new additions, for assorted lamb dishes, vegetarian starters and well-executed desserts.

The 412

Pittsburgher Ali Spagnola Releases an App Version of Her 'Power Hour' Album

Pittsburgher Ali Spagnola Releases an App Version of Her 'Power Hour' Album

The creator of the app — which takes any playlist on your smartphone or tablet and plays it in one-minute pieces — reminds users to please drink responsibly.
NPR Blog Team Tries, Critiques Primanti Bros. Sandwich

NPR Blog Team Tries, Critiques Primanti Bros. Sandwich

The group behind the station's Sandwich Monday blog series orders the iconic sandwich and writes a review.
Pittsburgh Has 'America's Ugliest Accent'

Pittsburgh Has 'America's Ugliest Accent'

The results of the Gawker poll are in: We’re No. 1.
'Yinzer Goosebumps' Series Parodies the Horrors of 'Burgh Life

'Yinzer Goosebumps' Series Parodies the Horrors of 'Burgh Life

The great Benstonium is at again with this set of faux book covers.

Hot Reads

Top 10

Top 10

Your 10 best bets for October.
Made in Pittsburgh

Made in Pittsburgh

The city of steel always has been known for its industry – what we make. Today, that defining characteristic expands beyond manufacturing into every aspect of modern life.
Ed Piskor is Pittsburgh's Hip-Hop Historian

Ed Piskor is Pittsburgh's Hip-Hop Historian

Comic-book artist Ed Piskor continues to win critical acclaim and international fame with his “Hip Hop Family Tree” series of graphic novels.
Review: Istanbul Sofra

Review: Istanbul Sofra

Head to Istanbul Sofra, one of Regent Square’s new additions, for assorted lamb dishes, vegetarian starters and well-executed desserts.
Review: Sienna Mercato

Review: Sienna Mercato

Matthew Porco, one of our Chefs of the Year, designs the menus at Sienna Mercato's downtown establishments.
Film Noir Fall Fashion

Film Noir Fall Fashion

Fall into autumn with a fashion landscape awash in black, white and nifty shades of gray.