Edit ModuleEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit ModuleShow Tags

Restaurant Review: Superior Motors

Kevin Sousa’s long-anticipated project fires on all cylinders as a restaurant. But, will it fulfill its larger mission?




photos by laura petrilla

 

The three-year saga surrounding the opening of Superior Motors played out like a serial.

In the beginning, Braddock Mayor John Fetterman invited Kevin Sousa, who grew up in McKees Rocks, another town on the outskirts of Pittsburgh decimated by the collapse of heavy industry, to the borough for a walk. Sousa eventually moved to Braddock and the two later settled on the restaurant’s location, with the promise of free rent and institutional support to rehabilitate a long abandoned automobile dealership.

Everything looked promising. There was buzz. And more buzz. A hyped-up, record-shattering Kickstarter campaign.

Then came a years-long pause in construction due to cost overruns and an unwillingness from banks to offer Sousa loans due to the perceived risk of opening a restaurant in Braddock and his shaky credit history surrounding his prior ventures: Salt of the Earth, Union Pig and Chicken, and Station Street.

The 2,000-plus Kickstarter backers waited to cash in on their rewards. “Will he ever open?” stories ran in local and national publications while at the same time, even though nothing had happened, “Kevin Sousa’s soon-to-open Superior Motors” became part of the oft-repeated, overwrought hymn praising Pittsburgh’s “booming foodie scene.”

It took an angel investor to step in as the lead of a small group of private financiers to get things going.

In July, Superior Motors opened.



In an early online look at the restaurant, I drew a comparison between Superior Motors and Salt of the Earth, Sousa’s 2010 Garfield restaurant that, alongside Dinette, Cure, Bar Marco and a few others, spurred Pittsburgh into its modern dining era. “If Salt was Sousa’s ‘Sense and Sensibility,’ this is his ‘Pride and Prejudice,’” I wrote. “It’s written in the same voice, but the characters are more compelling.” This still rings true.

As a restaurant, Superior Motors is pretty much exactly where it should be at this point in its development. The menu isn’t rooted in any particular cuisine, per se, so let’s call it “New American with hints of farm-to-table and an occasional detour to Japan.”



Just about everything is tasty. There are a handful of clunkers, such a chewy, over-fried skate wing, but, more often than not, the often-changing menu is enjoyable. As an example, I was thrilled with the textures, balanced flavors and bright plating of fresh-as-the-sea hamachi dressed with avocado, black garlic and pineapple.

That’s not to say that many dishes couldn’t use a little editing; Sousa’s style is more cerebral than soulful, which is fine because even though I’d sometimes like to see him cook more from the gut, he’s very good at what he does. Occasionally, though, that leads to overcomplicated offerings. For example, trout roe added color but no character to “Pork,” a dish that a friend loved (because he enjoys assembling a perfect bite every time) but other dining companions felt was too composed for its own good. “Tuna” was a stunning set piece of color, yet the cover was better than the story — a sea of bitter olive tapenade overwhelmed the meaty fish.



 

The main dining room is a grey study in poured concrete, with various levels creating a sense of movement. Snag one of the standard-height tables in the center of the room — make sure you get a seat that faces the dramatic flares coming from the Edgar Thomson Steel Works — and you’re set for a comfortable, lively evening. But the high-top tables on the far wall are long rectangles that jut away from diners — which can lead to awkward seating for groups of four — and it’s near-impossible to get cozy at the low lounge tables near the windows (the view from those seats is stunning, however). There also is a chill second dining room brightened with art by Pittsburgh-based Mia Tarducci (her work is on display throughout the restaurant) — depending on your mood you’ll either enjoy the quiet or feel isolated from the main action, as if you were banished to the kids’ table instead of being invited to the party.

The restaurant’s general manager, Chris Clark, acts as Sousa’s anchor and chief consigliare. Clark once was maitre d’ of WD-50 in New York and, prior to taking his current position, served as general manager of Mezzo Downtown. He is a confident leader, and he’s shepherding an exemplary front-of-house program. Some of the younger members of his diverse crew don’t have much or any restaurant experience, but missteps are small and quickly corrected.

Clark is responsible for setting the vibe, too. He and Sousa curate the tone of each evening with a selection of philosophically connected records (release year, influence of form, genre) played at pitch-perfect volume from start to finish. Clark says he’s also quick to change the plan if the energy in the room isn’t the anticipated reaction to the tunes.



Beverage director Jeremy Bustamante, who was always a reliable craftsman at Salt of the Earth and his other Pittsburgh gigs, struts his stirrer and his shaker stronger than ever at Superior Motors. Every cocktail, save for an undrinkable tomato concoction (hey, it had a nice aroma), was balanced, cleverly constructed to hit a specific flavor profile. Considering the drive back home, it’s a good thing “Vermouth,” a tart and slightly sour low-alcohol cocktail, was my favorite of the bunch.

Pastry chef Kate Carney’s big-time debut is a big success. Carney previously worked under James Beard semifinalist Casey Renee at Whitfield in East Liberty and also prepared desserts at Gaucho Parrilla Argentina in the Strip (and worked as a pizza-maker prior to that). I’m still thinking about her pavlova with its perfect crunchy crust and nougat interior, bolstered by a yuzu sauce taken to the point of tartness without crossing the line.

There’s no reason to think that Superior Motors won’t continue to get even better as it settles in. As it stands now, it’s an establishment that deserves to be part of Pittsburgh’s restaurant conversation.



But that conversation can’t just be about the food, service and drinks. Sousa’s long-term commitment to Braddock remains to be seen.

Sousa has gone to great lengths to assert that Superior Motors isn’t a fancy restaurant dropped into a low-income neighborhood because the price was right. He bills it as a “community restaurant and farm ecosystem” and often has stressed how important the inclusion of the Braddock community is to the success of the restaurant.

Yet right now it feels like Superior Motors largely is a destination restaurant for establishment diners feeling “brave” enough to go to a neighborhood they normally wouldn’t consider visiting, and for the cool kids who always are part of the scene.

Management worked with community leaders such as Mary Carey at the Braddock Carnegie Library to ensure that residents get a discount card; anyone who lives in the Braddock part of the 15104 ZIP code (Rankin and North Braddock are excluded) can come with a guest 18 times per year and receive a 50 percent discount on their food; a meal with two small plates and two entree-sized portions runs, with the discount, somewhere around $20 per person. I hope they use it, and, if they’re not, I hope the Superior Motors team reaches out to learn what’s keeping them from visiting.

Sousa and Clark are, at the very least, making inroads with whom they are employing. At any given time, according to Clark, 30 to 40 percent of the staff, both front- and back-of-house, are residents of Braddock. Although an early conversation about an apprentice program with the esteemed, community-focused nonprofit Grow Pittsburgh and its Braddock Farms never materialized, Sousa now looks to be in the nascent stage of a promised culinary training curriculum.

The adjacent lot that houses the Braddock Community Oven, a project funded in part by a grant stipulating that the oven is accessible for community use, might be a bellwether. It’s imperative that space, a longstanding meeting spot for neighborhood and nonprofit events that Sousa and his team now are using for a pizza offshoot called Parts & Service, remains open to the community, even if that means fewer pizza nights and private events for the restaurant.

At the end of the day, whether or not Superior Motors integrates its community mission with its mission as a restaurant will determine if this is a true transformative space or simply a very good place to eat.

1211 Braddock Ave., Braddock; 412/271-1022, superiormotors15104.com
 

Edit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module

Edit ModuleShow TagsEdit ModuleShow Tags
Edit Module Edit ModuleShow Tags

Andrew McCutchen: Thanks for the Memories

It's hard to overemphasize McCutchen's impact on the Pirates and its fan base.

How to Make a Mt. Washington Wedding Proposal Even Better

A lot of grooms-to-be propose on Mt. Washington. Not many decorate beforehand.

Bitter End’s Chicken Dinner Fundraiser

Chefs Becca Hegarty and Rick Easton to cook comfort food to help Hegarty’s mother.

Former Art Institute Housing to Be Converted into Condos

Downtown is booming as plans develop for yet another new apartment building.

Big Ben Not Ready to Retire –– But He's Making Plans

Ben Roethlisberger will do as many former athletes have and start the next phase of his career with a dining venture.

The Post is Quite Good, I, Tonya is Even Better

Reviews of "The Post," "I, Tonya" and "The Commuter," plus local movie news and notes.

Tequila Cowboy: Fine For Some, Apparently a Bad Idea for Others

The bar, which hosted a bizarre incident involving a top Steelers coach, is fine enough for the post-collegiate set.

Researchers and Pittsburgh Dad Agree - The ‘Man Flu’ is Real

There is now science to challenge the popular notion that men are wimps when sidelined by a cold.

High Praise - The Three Steelers Added to the Fight Song

The writers of one of the most familiar Steelers fight songs has updated the lyrics to include the teams newest stars.

Steelers Must Avoid ‘Captain Ahab’ Approach to the Jaguars

The Patriots are to the Steelers what Moby Dick was to Captain Ahab and that kind of obsession can backfire.

Drink and Get Inked at the Carnegie Science Center

The upcoming 21+ night will teach you about the science of body art.

Baby Loves Tacos is (For Real) Open in Bloomfield

Owner Zachary Shell stuffs his restaurant with tasty bites as he aims to fulfill a broader mission.

Thoughtful Entertainment

Humanities Festival will examine the state and direction of our society.

PM on KD: Winter HOME Issue

PM HOME Editor Jessica Sinichak appears on KDKA's Pittsburgh Today Live to discuss the big changes at the Kaufmann's building Downtown and how to decorate on a budget.

Lesson Learned: How Design Changed a North Allegheny Classroom

Frustrated by his sterile white classroom, teacher Greg Geibel earned an A+ from students when he transformed the space into something resembling a modern coffeehouse.
Edit Module
Edit ModuleShow Tags


Andrew McCutchen: Thanks for the Memories

Andrew McCutchen: Thanks for the Memories

It's hard to overemphasize McCutchen's impact on the Pirates and its fan base.

Comments

Big Ben Not Ready to Retire –– But He's Making Plans

Big Ben Not Ready to Retire –– But He's Making Plans

Ben Roethlisberger will do as many former athletes have and start the next phase of his career with a dining venture.

Comments


All the foodie news that's fit to blog
Bitter End’s Chicken Dinner Fundraiser

Bitter End’s Chicken Dinner Fundraiser

Chefs Becca Hegarty and Rick Easton to cook comfort food to help Hegarty’s mother.

Comments

Baby Loves Tacos is (For Real) Open in Bloomfield

Baby Loves Tacos is (For Real) Open in Bloomfield

Owner Zachary Shell stuffs his restaurant with tasty bites as he aims to fulfill a broader mission.

Comments


Not just good stuff. Great stuff.
Best of the ‘Burgh Gift Guide for 2017

Best of the ‘Burgh Gift Guide for 2017

Here are some of our favorite ‘Burgh-inspired gifts for him, her, kids, foodies and more.

Comments

Meet the Winner of Our 2017 Cutest Pet Contest

Meet the Winner of Our 2017 Cutest Pet Contest

The winner received the most votes among five dogs, four cats and a bunny.

Comments


Tequila Cowboy: Fine For Some, Apparently a Bad Idea for Others

Tequila Cowboy: Fine For Some, Apparently a Bad Idea for Others

The bar, which hosted a bizarre incident involving a top Steelers coach, is fine enough for the post-collegiate set.

Comments

Five Essential January Events in Pittsburgh

Five Essential January Events in Pittsburgh

Country crooners, unsung pop icons, on-ice acrobatics and more winter warmers.

Comments


Mike Prisuta's Sports Section

A weekly look at the games people are playing and the people who are playing them.
Steelers Must Avoid ‘Captain Ahab’ Approach to the Jaguars

Steelers Must Avoid ‘Captain Ahab’ Approach to the Jaguars

The Patriots are to the Steelers what Moby Dick was to Captain Ahab and that kind of obsession can backfire.

Comments

Fire Still Burns on Occasion for Still-Capable Penguins

Fire Still Burns on Occasion for Still-Capable Penguins

Wins over the Flyers and Blue Jackets might signal a turning point in what's been a mediocre stretch of hockey for a team from which much more is expected.

Comments


The movies that are playing in Pittsburgh –– and, more importantly, whether or not they're worth your time.
The Post is Quite Good, I, Tonya is Even Better

The Post is Quite Good, I, Tonya is Even Better

Reviews of "The Post," "I, Tonya" and "The Commuter," plus local movie news and notes.

Comments

Documentary Week at Row House Brings Fresh, Invigorating Films

Documentary Week at Row House Brings Fresh, Invigorating Films

Reviews of "Rat Film" and "Big Sonia," plus local movie news and notes.

Comments


Everything you need to know about getting married in Pittsburgh today.
How to Make a Mt. Washington Wedding Proposal Even Better

How to Make a Mt. Washington Wedding Proposal Even Better

A lot of grooms-to-be propose on Mt. Washington. Not many decorate beforehand.

Comments

These Elaborate Proposals Were Sure to Get a “Yes”

These Elaborate Proposals Were Sure to Get a “Yes”

Thinking of popping the question? Take a note from these grooms-to-be who set the bar high.

Comments


Weekly inspiration for your home from the editors of Pittsburgh Magazine
Former Art Institute Housing to Be Converted into Condos

Former Art Institute Housing to Be Converted into Condos

Downtown is booming as plans develop for yet another new apartment building.

Comments

Lesson Learned: How Design Changed a North Allegheny Classroom

Lesson Learned: How Design Changed a North Allegheny Classroom

Frustrated by his sterile white classroom, teacher Greg Geibel earned an A+ from students when he transformed the space into something resembling a modern coffeehouse.

Comments